Grandma's Amish Sugar Cream Pie Recipe (2024)

Last Updated on: August 31, 2023

Have you ever had a slice of Amish sugar cream pie?

No? Then get ready to fall in love because this old-fashioned dessert is decadent, sweet, and oh-so-creamy.

Like most Amish recipes, this dessert is super simple and delicious. It needs ten ingredients, but they’re all pantry staples.

If you like Chess pie, you have to try this simpler version. They’re similar, but Amish sugar cream pie doesn’t contain eggs to make the vanilla custard.

Still, it’s ultra-rich and sweet, and I know you’ll love it.

What Is Amish Sugar Cream Pie?

Amish sugar cream pie is what’s known as a “make-do” pie. This means the baker had to “make-do” with what they had in the cupboard.

It features sugar, milk, cornstarch, and margarine. And while it’s very straightforward, the silky smooth custard is hard to resist.

Believe it or not, this is one of those Amish pie recipes that dates back over 200 years. And it’s so popular it was named the official state pie of Indiana in 2009!

You might hear it called “finger pie” because some bakers stir the pie ingredients with their fingers to prevent air bubbles.

We’ll use a spatula. Oh, and go for a store-bought pie crust to make things easy.

Ingredients

As mentioned, this pie calls for pantry staples. So, here’s what you need to make this delectable dessert:

• White Sugar: You can’t have a sugar cream pie without sugar! Don’t worry, it’s not too much sugar.

• Salt: A pinch of salt helps to balance out the sweetness. It takes the flavors from flat to full in no time!

• Half-and-half: This helps to bring the creamy element to the pie filling. Whole milk could be used in a pinch, but you don’t want it to be too thin.

• Whipping Cream: Whipping cream will make the pie filling ultra-creamy. If you only have half-and-half, you can use that for the full cream amount.

• Brown Sugar: While you can use just white sugar, adding brown sugar gives it a deeper flavor.

• Cornstarch: This is what thickens the custard without any eggs.

• Margarine or Butter: Not all sugar cream pies call for butter, but I think it makes for the best pie.

• Vanilla: A splash of vanilla adds a touch of warmth.

• Pie Crust: Make your own, or use a pre-made crust. Either way, it’s the filling that makes the pie!

• Spices: While totally optional, a sprinkle of nutmeg and cinnamon adds great flavor to the pie.

How to Make Amish Sugar Cream Pie

Have I already mentioned that this pie is super easy to make?

Here’s a step-by-step summary as proof, and you’ll find more detailed instructions below.

1. Prepare the crust for baking. Preheat the oven and place the pie crust on a baking tray.

2. Make the pie filling. Boil the cream, half-and-half, white sugar, and salt. Gradually mix in brown sugar, butter, and cornstarch. Then whisk the mixture until thick and creamy.

3. Bake the pie. Pour the pie filling into the crust, and bake for 25 minutes, or until a golden crust begins to form on top.

For an extra touch of flavor, sprinkle some spices over the top when it comes out of the oven.

Tips for The Best Sugar Cream Pie

With such an easy recipe, it’s really hard to go wrong!

But there are a few tricks you can use to make sure you get the best sugar cream pie possible.

• Bake the pie over a cookie sheet to prevent messes in the oven. Depending on how deep the pie dish is, the custard may spill over while baking. So, add a cookie sheet to catch any drips.

• Don’t overbake the pie. It should be jiggly, or maybe even a touch runny when you take it out of the oven. Let it sit or chill in the fridge to set up properly.

• Store leftovers in the refrigerator. Because it is cream based, letting it sit at room temperature will cause a spoiled pie in no time.

• Serve with fresh berries on top. A splash of color and bright flavor goes great with this pie.

• Blind baking the pie crust. Since the filling is so wet, this will just ensure the pastry cooks properly. Also, add a layer of foil to the edges so they don’t burn.

How to Store and Freeze

As I said before, it’s important to store this pie in the fridge. The cream base will quickly sour if you don’t!

• To store in the refrigerator: Cover the cold pie with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 3-5 days.

• To freeze: Cover the cold pie with plastic wrap, and store it in the freezer for up to six months.

Thaw in the fridge overnight and enjoy!

More Old Fashioned Treats You’ll Love

Moon Pies
Chess Pie
Mock Apple Pie
Tea Cakes
Buttermilk Pie

Grandma’s Amish Sugar Cream Pie Recipe

Servings

8

servings

See Also

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pinwheel Fudge - The Recipe Rebel

Prep time

10

minutes

Cooking time

30

minutes

Calories

395

kcal

Have you ever had a slice of Amish sugar cream pie? No? Then get ready to fall in love because this old-fashioned dessert is rich, sweet, and oh-so-creamy.

Ingredients

• 1 premade, deep dish pie crust

• 3/4 cup white sugar

• 1/8 teaspoon salt

• 2 cups half-and-half

• 1/2 cup whipping cream

• 1/4 cup brown sugar

• 1/4 cup cornstarch

• 1/2 cup margarine or butter

• 1 teaspoon vanilla

• ground nutmeg and cinnamon (optional)

Instructions

• Preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit (205°C) and place the ready-made pie crust on a baking tray. (If blind baking, bake the crust for 10 minutes and let cool while preparing the filling.)
• In a large saucepan, mix the white sugar, salt, half-and-half, and whipping cream. Bring the mixture to a boil, mixing constantly.
• Add the brown sugar and cornstarch to a large bowl and mix well to combine.
• Slowly pour the hot cream mixture into the bowl, whisking constantly until about half of the cream is blended.
• Whisk gently until smooth, then pour the brown sugar-cream mixture into the saucepan with the rest of the cream mixture.
• Add butter or margarine and cook over medium heat.
• Continue whisking for 5 minutes, or until thick. Then reduce the heat to low, stir in vanilla, and simmer for another minute.
• Pour the pie mixture into the pie crust, sprinkle over the cinnamon and nutmeg (if using), and bake for 10 minutes.
• Turn the oven down to 350°F/175°C and bake for another 25 minutes, until golden brown.
• Let the pie cool completely before serving.

Notes

• Be sure to get a deep-dish pie crust or split the filling between 2 regular crusts.
• Use real butter for a richer flavor.
• Blind bake the crust for 10 minutes, then cover the edges with foil to keep them from burning.